The Messiah vs The Christ Part 4

B"H

Bezrat HaShem

The Yeshua the world should have been given and still willing to be recieved...

The Jewish Yeshua...

Understanding the Yeshua the world should have been given, we have to understand Yeshua’s relationship with True Torah Judaism is crucial for grasping the essence of his teachings and the context in which he operated. As a rabbi deeply entrenched in Jewish tradition, Yeshua engaged with the Torah not just The Torah’s legal requirements, but as a living framework that guided ethical behavior and community life. His interpretations often highlighted the dynamic nature of Halacha, suggesting that rigid adherence to the law could overshadow its underlying principles of love, mercy, and justice. Through various encounters and teachings, Yeshua not only affirmed the importance of the Torah and Rabbinic observance, but also invited his followers to reconsider how to spiritualize their observance.

This framework is essential when examining the Pharisaic context in which Yeshua operated. The Pharisees, known for their commitment to interpreting the law and shaping communal practices, played a pivotal role in the religious landscape of first-century Judaism and the shaping of Rabbinic Judaism. By understanding Yeshua's teachings in relation to Pharisaic thought. This exploration of Yeshua’s love for Torah, his critiques of religious practices, and his inclusive approach to faith offers valuable insights into his legacy and invites people to reflect on how these principles can inform their own spiritual journeys.

1. Yeshua and Halacha (Jewish Law)

Yeshua’s relationship with Halacha, or Jewish law, serves as a vital lens through which we can understand his teachings and practices. Historical accounts within the Gospels illustrate that Yeshua adhered to the Torah, exemplifying his deep commitment to Jewish legal principles. In Mark 2:23-28, for example, Yeshua defends his disciples for plucking grain on Shabbat, suggesting that his interpretation of the law allows for flexibility under specific circumstances. This indicates not only his knowledge of Halachic norms but also his willingness to engage in interpretative dialogue with the law. The Rambam (Maimonides) discusses similar permissibility regarding actions taken on Shabbat, thereby reinforcing the notion that Yeshua’s behavior aligns with Halachic understanding. By navigating the complexities of the law, Yeshua exemplified a rabbi who was deeply engaged with Jewish tradition, simultaneously inviting his followers to rethink rigid interpretations.This dynamic engagement with Halacha positions Yeshua as a pivotal figure within the Jewish religious landscape of his time, emphasizing his commitment to the essence of the Torah. Such a framework encourages modern followers to explore the rich tradition of Jewish law and its relevance in their lives today, fostering a deeper understanding of faith and practice.

2. Washing of Hands

The ritual practice of washing hands holds particular significance in the context of Yeshua's observance of Jewish customs and traditions. In Mark 7:1-5, we learn that some of Yeshua's disciples did not wash their hands before eating, which raised eyebrows among the Pharisees and prompted discussions about ritual purity. Importantly, the Gospel does not explicitly state that Yeshua himself neglected this practice (this points to fact that he would have washed his hands). This absence highlights the necessity of contextualizing the text within the broader spectrum of Jewish law. Moreover, discussions in the Gemara, especially in Mesechet Berachos, reveal that handwashing is not explicitly mandated by the Torah, but is rather a rabbinic tradition that is implemented as halacha 200-300 years later. This distinction illuminates the diversity of opinions regarding ritual observance during Yeshua's time, reflecting the dynamic nature of Jewish law. By addressing these differing viewpoints, Yeshua emphasized the significance of intention and the heart in religious observance. His teachings suggest that the essence of the law extends beyond mere ritualistic adherence, advocating for a deeper relationship with God. This nuanced understanding of ritual practices invites followers to consider the spirit behind their actions, encouraging them to engage with traditions in a meaningful and thoughtful manner.

3. Pharisaic Context

Understanding Yeshua within the Pharisaic context is essential for grasping the full significance of his teachings and interactions. The Pharisees were a prominent sect within Judaism, dedicated to interpreting the law and shaping communal practices. As a rabbi, Yeshua operated within this tradition, engaging with existing interpretations while sometimes challenging prevailing norms. His teachings often aligned with Pharisaic thought, reflecting a shared commitment to the law, but he also introduced unique perspectives that sought to deepen the understanding of Jewish ethics. For instance, in Matthew 23, Yeshua uphold Pharisaic tradition because the Pharisee sit in the seat of moses and at the same time critiques certain Pharisaic practices, advocating for a focus not only the observance of Torah which is paramount but also on the spirit of the law. This dichotomy position Yeshua as both a follower of Jewish law and an active participant in the vibrant discussions of Jewish Spirituality that characterized his era. By engaging with Pharisaic thought, he highlights the importance of ethical behavior, compassion, and justice in religious practice. Understanding Yeshua within this framework allows us to appreciate the complexities of his teachings and their enduring relevance, encouraging contemporary followers to reflect on how these principles can be integrated into their lives.

4. Yeshua's Love of Torah

Yeshua's teachings consistently reflect a profound love for the Torah, illustrating his deep commitment to Jewish law and ethics. Throughout the Gospels, he emphasizes the importance of following the commandments and living a life aligned with the moral principles outlined in the Torah. In Matthew 22:37-40, Yeshua encapsulates the essence of the commandments by teaching that the greatest commandment is to love God with all one's heart and the second is to love one's neighbor as oneself. This articulation not only underscores his reverence for the Torah but also conveys its ethical core. Yeshua’s engagement with the law emphasizes its transformative power and relevance to everyday life, encouraging his followers to see the Torah as a living document that speaks to their circumstances. By modeling a love for the Torah, Yeshua invites individuals to cultivate a relationship with the mitzvot and halakhot that not just only in religious observance (which is paramount), but to open the curtain into the divine; emphasizing the significance of intention and heartfelt obedience to God’s will. His teachings challenge followers to internalize these values, promoting a faith that is both deeply rooted in tradition and dynamically responsive to the challenges of contemporary life.

5. Yeshua's Teachings and Critiques

Yeshua’s interactions with various individuals, including the Roman centurion, the Canaanite woman, and the Samaritan woman, offer profound insights into his approach to faith and identity. His remarks often challenge the prevailing attitudes of his time, inviting deeper reflection on issues of belief and belonging. For instance, when addressing the Roman centurion, Yeshua acknowledges the centurion's remarkable faith, stating that many will not believe without witnessing signs and wonders. In his encounter with the Canaanite woman, Yeshua refers to her as a "dog," a statement that, while seemingly harsh, serves to provoke thought and demonstrate the woman's resilience in faith. Her response leads Yeshua to commend her faith, highlighting the transformative potential of genuine belief.

Yeshua also critiqued the Pharisees for their focus on outward appearances and legalistic practices, emphasizing the need for genuine faith and compassion. In Matthew 23, he admonishes them for burdening others with strict rules while failing to embody the law's essence. This critique parallels the Talmudic Rabbis, who similarly addressed the Pharisees’ hypocrisy, particularly in tractates like Sotah 22 (And those who injure themselves out of false abstinence pharisees are people who erode the world.), where they warn against engaging in ritual practices devoid of heartfelt intention. The Talmud teaches that a person should not be overly strict in a way that burdens others, emphasizing moral integrity over mere legal compliance. By navigating these nuanced encounters, we see Yeshua's ability to challenge and uplift, inviting those he encountered into a deeper understanding of their spiritual journeys.

6. Yeshua's Love for Jews and compassion Non-Jews

Yeshua's interactions reveal a deep love and compassion for both Jews and some non-Jews, showcasing his commitment to inclusivity and understanding. While some of his statements may seem critical, they often carry profound messages inviting individuals into a transformative relationship with God. For instance, his engagement with the Samaritan woman at the well exemplifies his willingness to cross societal boundaries and offer hope and acceptance. This encounter not only challenges the societal norms of his time but also illustrates Yeshua’s approach to faith as accessible to all people, regardless of their background.

By emphasizing love, mercy, and understanding, Yeshua advocates for building a community that transcends ethnic and cultural divisions. His teachings encourage individuals to recognize their shared humanity, fostering a spirit of inclusivity that mirrors the teachings of the Torah. This commitment to love, acceptance, and have compassion underscores the transformative potential of faith, encouraging both Jews and non-Jews to seek a deeper relationship with the Divine. Yeshua’s life and teachings provide a model for contemporary followers, inviting them to engage with their communities through compassion and understanding.

7. Inclusion of Non-Jews

The question of how non-Jews fit into the Yeshua movement raises essential considerations about the nature of faith and community. In the absence of Pauline doctrine, it is plausible that Yeshua's teachings would stress the necessity of Gentiles embracing Jewish practices and beliefs as integral to their faith journey. Historical context plays a significant role, particularly regarding the Samaritans, who held cultural and religious ties to Judaism despite being viewed as outsiders. Yeshua’s interactions with non-Jews reveal a commitment to inclusivity, but they also reflect the complexities of identity and expectations of conversion. His teachings suggest that acceptance into the faith community would require a commitment to the principles of Judaism, thus indicating a pathway for non-Jews to participate in the Yeshua movement fully. By addressing these nuances, we gain insights into how Yeshua envisioned the relationship between Jews and non-Jews. This discussion emphasizes the importance of dialogue, respect, and understanding in fostering a faith community that reflects the values of love and compassion central to Yeshua's message.

8. The Role of Paul

The role of Paul in shaping the Yeshua movement is critical, especially when considering the theological implications of his writings. Paul’s teachings introduced concepts that diverged from Yeshua’s original message, particularly regarding the relationship between faith, works, and the inclusion of Gentiles. For instance, Paul often emphasized faith in Christ as the means of salvation, which can downplay the importance of Torah observance in the eyes of many. This theological shift raises questions about whether Paul’s influence has overshadowed Yeshua’s teachings, leading followers to prioritize different aspects of their faith. Furthermore, Paul’s assertion that Gentiles could belong to the faith community without fully adhering to Jewish law presents a significant departure from traditional Jewish expectations. By examining the interplay between Yeshua's message and Pauline theology, we gain insights into the complexities of early Christian identity and the ongoing dialogue regarding the role of the Torah in the life of faith.

9. The Nature of the Yeshua Movement

Speculating on the nature of the Yeshua movement today, without the influence of the Gentile church and Pauline doctrine, presents a fascinating exploration of faith and practice. In such a scenario, it is likely that followers of Yeshua would maintain a strong emphasis on Torah observance, focusing on the ethical and moral teachings found within its pages. The movement would be with traditional Judaism, deeply grounded in community, rituals, and the teachings of the Torah. As a Pharisaic rabbi, Yeshua would likely encourage a return to foundational Jewish practices, emphasizing love, justice, and mercy as central tenets of faith. The community could evolve into a vibrant hub for learning, discussion, and the practice of mitzvot and halacha, reflecting the values Yeshua espoused. Additionally, this movement would foster inclusivity, inviting non-Jews to embrace Jewish practices through conversion and commitment to the ethical dimensions of the Torah. Yeshua’s call for genuine faith and personal connection to God would be paramount, inspiring followers to live out their beliefs in practical and transformative ways. Ultimately, without the complexities introduced by Pauline theology, the Yeshua movement could remain rooted in Jewish tradition, inviting a rich dialogue about the nature of faith, identity, and community.

In the end, if the Yeshua’s followers made Torah and Judaism as a whole paramount, and put the words of Paul at a lower level it might have developed into a vibrant expression of Judaism that emphasizes the relevance of the Torah in everyday life. Yeshua's commitment to Halacha underscores the transformative potential of Jewish law, serving as a guiding light for ethical conduct and communal responsibility. By advocating for genuine faith rooted in intention and compassion, Yeshua inspires a re-engagement with traditional practices, fostering a sense of belonging that transcends cultural boundaries in the contents of the Jewish religion. This vision invites individuals to see the Torah as a living document that not only connects them to their spiritual heritage but also empowers them to navigate the challenges of modern existence.

Ultimately, having Yeshua’s words as paramount in this exploration underscores the enduring relevance of his teachings within the Jewish tradition. His approach to inclusivity and acceptance suggests that the essence of faith lies not only on ritual adherence (which is paramount) but in cultivating a heartfelt relationship with God and fellow human beings. Followers of Yeshua (Which Shtiebel on the Hill openly accept) today seek to understand his legacy, they are encouraged to prioritize his teachings and delve into the rich tapestry of Jewish tradition, recognizing that genuine faith is both a personal journey and a collective responsibility. This ongoing exploration offers a pathway for living out the principles of love, compassion, and justice that Yeshua exemplified, creating a community that reflects the core values of his message.